| # |
| 4 Friends Auto Sales | 3219 West Washington Street, Historic Ransom Place | | | |
| 465 Auto Sales | 4705 West Washington Street, Venerable Flackville | | | |
| 6767 Auto Salesnot edited since 2019 | 6767 West Washington Street, Valley Mills | 6767autosales.com | +1-317-244-2277 | |
| A |
| A Team Autos | 4120 East New York Street, Grace Tuxedo | | | |
| A-1 Auto & Truck, Inc. | 3515 West Washington Street, Riverside | | | |
| Active Auto Sales LLC | 2735 Madison Avenue, University Heights | | | |
| Advanced Auto Sales | 5269 East Washington Street, Irvington | | | |
| ATZ Auto Sales LLC | 2534 Bluff Road, Old Southside | | | |
| Automobiles For Less | 1112 South Lynhurst Drive, Venerable Flackville | | | |
| B |
| Big Wheel Motors | 1705 Oliver Avenue, Old Southside | | | |
| Bill Estes Chevrolet | 4105 West 96th Street, New Augusta | | | |
| Billie Milam Used Cars | 2951 Shelby Street, University Heights | | | |
| Blossom Troca Dealership | 1752 North Shadeland Avenue, Warren Park | | | |
| Blue's Auto Sales | 2511 East Washington Street, Westminster/St. Philip Neri | | | |
| Borimex Auto Sales LLC | 5661 West Washington Street, Valley Mills | | | |
| Bradford Auto Sales | 1047 South East Street, Fletcher Place | | | |
| C |
| Capitol City FordFord | 8623 East Washington Street, Washington Place | | | |
| D |
| D&B Auto Salesnot edited since 2021 | 3898 North Keystone Avenue, Watson Park | | | |
| Daniels Auto Sales | 3206 West Washington Street, Historic Ransom Place | | | |
| Decatur Auto Sales | 3201 Kentucky Avenue, Sunshine Gardens | | | |
| E |
| Eastgate Chrysler Jeep Dodge Ram | 500 North Shadeland Avenue, Warren Park | | | |
| Eastside Motorsnot edited since 2022 | 4506 East 10th Street, Little Flower | | | |
| Economy Auto Sales LLCnot edited since 2021 | Willard Park, no street on record | | | |
| F |
| Family Automotive | 4401 East Michigan Street, Grace Tuxedo | | | |
| G |
| Galaxy Auto Corporationnot edited since 2019 | 9445 Haver Way, Sherwood Forest | | | |
| H |
| Hanna's Auto Salesnot edited since 2021 | 4545 North Keystone Avenue, Canterbury–Chatard | | | |
| Henry's Auto Sales | 2313 East Washington Street, Westminster/St. Philip Neri | | | |
| Honest Abe Auto Sales - Keystone Avenot edited since 2021 | Canterbury–Chatard, no street on record | | | |
| Honest Karl's Used Bikes And Carsnot edited since 2021 | Friends and Neighbors, no street on record | | | |
| Hubler Toyota | 8055 US 31 South, Southport | hublertoyota.com | +1-317-882-2600 | |
| I |
| IAA Vehicle Purchasing | 3302 South Harding Street, Sunshine Gardens | | | |
| INDY TRUCKS | 9431 Threel Road, Sherwood Forest | | | |
| Indy's Finest Cars | 3726 East 10th Street, Brookside | | | |
| M |
| Members Auto Source | 438 Virginia Avenue, Fletcher Place | | | |
| Mike's Auto Sales | 2360 Prospect Street, Fountain Square | | | |
| N |
| New 2 You | 5241 English Avenue, Christian Park | | | |
| Newrides | 4501 East Michigan Street, Bosart-Brown | | | |
| Northside Auto | 7603 East 96th Street, Castleton | northside-auto.com | +1-317-622-4090 | |
| P |
| PLS Auto | 4701 West 38th Street, International Marketplace | pls247.com | +1-317-677-1444 | |
| Premier Acceptancenot edited since 2022 | 7520 East Washington Street, Washington Place | | | |
| Prestige Auto Salesnot edited since 2013 | Ameriplex, no street on record | | | |
| Q |
| Quality Motors Incnot edited since 2022 | 5202 Lafayette Road, International Marketplace | | | |
| R |
| Ray Skillman Chevroletnot edited since 2013 | New Bethel Subdivision, no street on record | | | |
| S |
| Selective Motors | 4325 Allisonville Road, Oliver Johnson's Woods | | | |
| Smith Auto Sales | 3202 English Avenue, Englewood | | | |
| T |
| Tesla IndianapolisTesla | 8280 Castleton Corner Drive, Allisonville | tesla.com | +1-317-814-6667 | |
| Top Shelf Auto Sales | 3301 East New York Street, Robson-Voorhees | | | |
| Toyota | Arlington Woods, no street on record | | | |
| Turbo Auto Sales | 3770 West Washington Street, Riverside | turboautosalesindy.com | +1 317-492-9617 | |
| W |
| Will's Auto Sales | 1716 East Washington Street, Arsenal Heights | | | |