| A |
| Adam Altis AgencyAmerican Family Insurance | 6111 West Bluemound Road, Bluemound Heights | | | |
| Adam Altis Insurance AgencyAmerican Family Insurance | 3855 South 60th Street, Green Moor | amfam.com | +1-414-321-9944 | |
| Allrisk Financial Services | 5628 West Vliet Street, Hawthorne Glen | getinsurancequote.us | +1 414-461-9759 | |
| Allstate Insurance Agent Dave KelleyAllstate | 5913 West Howard Avenue, Green Moor | agents.allstate.com | +1-414-988-5271 | |
| American Advantage Insurance Groupnot edited since 2022 | Jackson Park, no street on record | | | |
| American Advantage Thai Vang | 7212 West Fond du Lac Avenue, Long View | | +1-414-254-7714 | |
| American Family Insurance | 3457 South Kinnickinnic Avenue, Fernwood | | | |
| American Family Insurance - Jaime MercadoAmerican Family Insurance | 709 West Layton Avenue, Mitchell West | | | |
| C |
| Charles V. Vang Insurance Agency | 3616 West National Avenue, Silver City | cvvinsurance.com | +1-414-649-8331 | |
| Cyndy Johnson Allstate AgencyAllstate | Sherman Park, no street on record | agents.allstate.com | | |
| D |
| Derold Barker AgencyAmerican Family Insurance | 2215 East North Avenue, East Side | | +1 414-332-8350 | |
| F |
| Freeway Insurance | Mitchell Park, no street on record | | | |
| G |
| GBG Insurance Agencynot edited since 2018 | 1930 North Doctor Martin Luther King Junior Drive, Halyard Park | gbginsurance.com | +1 414 264 1400 | |
| J |
| James D. Rouse Agency, Inc.American Family Insurance | 8201 West Capitol Drive, Saint Aemilian's | amfam.com | +1 414-527-3011 | |
| M |
| Martin Manley Insurance AgencyAmerican Family Insurance | 3927 South 76th Street, Woodland Court | amfam.com | +1-414-546-3338 | |
| Michael Voss Insurance AgencyAmerican Family Insurance | Honey Creek Parkway, no street on record | | | |
| N |
| Northwestern Mutual Tower and CommonsNorthwestern Mutual | 800 East Wisconsin Avenue, Juneau Town | northwesternmutual.com | | |
| S |
| Santiago Insurance Agency | 828 West Historic Mitchell Street, Historic Mitchell Street | | +1 414-727-8284 | |
| Schwade Insurance Agency, Inc.not edited since 2022 | 8131 West Capitol Drive, Saint Aemilian's | | | |
| Stoecker & Associates, Inc.American Advantage Insurance Groupnot edited since 2022 | 5128 West Bluemound Road, Story Hill | | +1-414-462-1335 | |
| T |
| The Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance Company Corporate Headquartersnot edited since 2021 | 720 East Wisconsin Avenue, Juneau Town | northwesternmutual.com | +1 414 271 1444 | |