| A |
| Acme Pet Food | 628 Vanderbilt Avenue, Flatbush | | +1-718-789-8062 | |
| Amazing Pet Supply | 2366 86th Street, New Utrecht | | +1-607-590-3565 | |
| Animal Pantrynot edited since 2022 | 693 86th Street, New Utrecht | | +1 718 680 2220 | |
| Animal Pantry Ozone Parknot edited since 2019 | 90-21;137-20 Albert Road;Cross Bay Boulevard, East New York | | | |
| Aquarium Petsnot edited since 2018 | 135-02 Northern Boulevard, Flushing | | | |
| B |
| Biscuits & Bath | 487 3rd Avenue, Midtown | biscuitsandbath.com | +1-646-786-0971 | |
| Biscuits & Bath - Hell's Kitchen | Manhattan, no street on record | | | |
| Bob's Tropical Pet Groomingnot edited since 2022 | 57-45 Myrtle Avenue, Bushwick | bobstropicalpetcenter.com | +1-718-821-2872 | |
| Bushwick Barknot edited since 2022 | 175 Knickerbocker Avenue, Bushwick | bushwickbark.com | +1-718-928-7772 | |
| Bushy Tailsnot edited since 2018 | 1087 Flushing Avenue, Bushwick | bushytailsbrooklyn.com | +1-718-821-1525 | |
| C |
| Canine Styles | 2200 Broadway, Upper West Side | caninestyles.com | +1-212-799-9799 | |
| Citipupsnot edited since 2020 | 166 8th Avenue, Midtown | citipups.com | +1-888-400-0859 | |
| D |
| District Dog | 144 Driggs Avenue, Williamsburg | districtdog.com | +1-718-290-7434 | |
| F |
| Furry Fiends | Washington Heights, no street on record | | | |
| Furry Pawsnot edited since 2022 | 1705 3rd Avenue, Upper East Side | | +1-212-528-5308 | |
| G |
| George's Plants & Pets | 8527 3rd Avenue, New Utrecht | | +1-718-930-4767 | |
| Gone To The Dogs | 103 7th Avenue, Flatbush | gonetothedogs.co | +1-201-375-3471 | |
| Grand Ave. Pet Shop | Elmhurst, no street on record | | | |
| Greenland Pet Shop | 33 West End Avenue, Manhattan | | +1-212-956-9600 | |
| I |
| I Love My Petnot edited since 2021 | 901 Nostrand Avenue, Brooklyn | | +1-718-576-6535 | |
| J |
| Just Food For Dogs | 2025 Broadway, Upper West Side | justfoodfordogs.com | +1 -332-205-7888 | |
| L |
| Little Creatures | 305 Columbus Avenue, Upper West Side | littlecreaturesnyc.com | +1-212-799-2222 | |
| M |
| Manhattan Aquariumsnot edited since 2019 | 522 West 37th Street, Manhattan | aquariumsnewyork.com | +1-310-923-7929 | |
| Modern Pet | Flushing, no street on record | mymodernpet.net | +1-718-224-8500 | |
| Mr. Friendly | 228 Clifton Place, Williamsburg | mrfriendly.nyc | +1-718-489-3575 | |
| N |
| Natty Pet Shop | 620 Washington Avenue, Flatbush | nattypetshop.com | +1-718-975-4414 | |
| NY Tailsnot edited since 2019 | 318 East 80th Street, Upper East Side | nytails.com | +1-646-2891760 | |
| NYC Pet | 350 7th Avenue, Flatbush | nycpet.com | +1-718-768-3954 | |
| NYCPet | 475 Driggs Avenue, Williamsburg | nycpet.com | +1-718-218-7101 | |
| P |
| Pacific Aquarium | 46 Delancey Street, Lower Manhattan | | +1-212-995-5895 | |
| Pet Island | 10-50 Jackson Avenue, Long Island City | | +1 718-786-1555 | |
| Pet Market NYC | 2821 Broadway, Harlem | petmarketnyc.com | +1-212-864-3300 | |
| Pet Townnot edited since 2022 | 1676 1st Avenue, Upper East Side | pettown.business.site | +1 212-996-6273 | |
| Petco | 165 Bricktown Way, Staten Island | stores.petco.com | +1 718-569-3011 | |
| Petland Discounts | 167 East 125th Street, Harlem | | | |
| Petopia | 226 West 116th Street, Harlem | nycpetopia.com | +1-212-222-7089 | |
| Pets On The Run | 989 Manhattan Avenue, Long Island City | frommfamily.com | +1-718-389-0650 | |
| PetSmart | 1525 Forest Avenue, Staten Island | petsmart.com | +1 929-308-2634 | |
| Popcorn Pawz - Inwood | 4771 Broadway, Washington Heights | popcornpawz.com | +1-646-755-8190 | |
| R |
| Royal Birds & Supplies | 113-13 Atlantic Avenue, Queens | | +1-718-414-9669 | |
| S |
| Skillman Pets | 49-16 Skillman Avenue, Woodside | skillmanpets.com | +1 718-803-3635 | |
| SNL Fish N Birds | 3594 Nostrand Avenue, Flatlands | snlfishnbirds.com | +1-917-921-5102 | |
| Spoiled Brats | Washington Heights, no street on record | | | |
| Sweet Pawsnot edited since 2022 | Brooklyn, no street on record | | +1-347-339-7139 | |
| T |
| The Pet Parlornot edited since 2017 | 1129 Morris Park Avenue, The Bronx | | | |
| W |
| Wagging Tails | Queens, no street on record | | | |
| WE | 152 West 24th Street, Midtown | bideawee.com | +1 866-262-8133 | |
| Wespaw Pets | 44-05 Queens Boulevard, Woodside | wespawpets.com | +1 718-706-8100 | |
| Whiskers Holistic Petcare | 235 East 9th Street, Lower Manhattan | 1800whiskers.com | +1-212-979-2532 | |
| Whole Pets Marketnot edited since 2022 | 1216 Fulton Street, Brooklyn | | | |