| A |
| Addeo Bakers | 2372 Hughes Avenue, The Bronx | addeobakers.com | +1-718-367-8316 | |
| Allan's Bakery | 166 Allen Street, Lower Manhattan | allansbakery.com | +1-347-988-0157 | |
| Andre’s Hungarian Bakery | 100-28 Queens Boulevard, Elmhurst | andresbakery.org | +1-718-830-0266 | |
| Aunt Butchie's | 8224 3rd Avenue, New Utrecht | auntbutchies.com | +1-718-256-2933 | |
| B |
| Bake Culturenot edited since 2022 | 48 Bowery, Lower Manhattan | bakecultureusa.com | +1-646-858-2898 | |
| Baked in Brooklyn | 755 5th Avenue, Flatbush | bakedinbrooklynny.com | +1-718-788-3164 | |
| Bakeri Queens | 8-18 Woodward Avenue, Bushwick | bakeribrooklyn.com | +1-347-463-9054 | |
| Barachou | 449 Amsterdam Avenue, Upper West Side | barachou.com | +1-646-398-7788 | |
| Berikoni Georgian Bakery | 125 Brighton Beach Avenue, Coney Island | | +1-718-708-5040 | |
| Billy's Bakery | 410 Columbus Avenue, Upper West Side | billysbakerynyc.com | +1-347-894-2024 | |
| Boardwalk Bagel | 108-01 Beach 108th Street, Rockaway Park | boardwalkbagel.com | | |
| Bonjour Brooklyn | 1357 Broadway, Bushwick | bonjourbrooklyn.com | +1-718-443-2200 | |
| Brooklyn French Bakers | 510 2nd Street, Flatbush | brooklynfrenchbakers.com | +1-332-250-0582 | |
| Brother’s Bakery Cafe | 2155 2nd Avenue, Harlem | brothersbakerycafe.com | +1 212 641 0646 | |
| By the Way Bakery | 1236 Lexington Avenue, Upper East Side | btwbakery.com | +1 212-988-3300 | |
| C |
| Cafe Con Pan Bakery Corp. II | 32 New Dorp Plaza, Staten Island | cafeconpanny.com | +1 347-861-0364 | |
| Corrado Bread & Pastry | 1360 Lexington Avenue, Upper East Side | corradobreadandpastry.com | +1 212-348-8943 | |
| Cuccio's Bakery | 320 Avenue X, Coney Island | cucciosbakeshop.com | +1-718-336-1944 | |
| Custom Cakes NYC Inc. | 80-05 168th Street, Queens | customcakesnycinc.com | +1 718-969-1800 | |
| D |
| Don Paco Lopez Panaderíanot edited since 2021 | 2129 3rd Avenue, Harlem | donpacolopez.com | +1 212-876-0700 | |
| Dutch Baby | 813 West 187th Street, Washington Heights | dutchbabybakery.com | +1-646-559-2441 | |
| E |
| E & L Bakery Care | 4202 White Plains Road, The Bronx | eandlbakery.com | +1-718-324-8152 | |
| Ess-a-Bagel | 324 1st Avenue, Midtown | essabagel.com | +1-212-260-2252 | |
| F |
| Flavas Bakery Jamaican Flavorsnot edited since 2019 | 147-95B Farmers Boulevard, Far Rockaway | | | |
| Fort Washington Bakery & Deli | 808 West 181st Street, Washington Heights | | | |
| G |
| Greenberg's Bagels | 1065 Bedford Avenue, Williamsburg | greenbergsbagels.com | +1-347-789-6876 | |
| H |
| Homestead Gourmet Shop | 81-45 Lefferts Boulevard, Queens | | +1 718-849-1366 | |
| I |
| I Love Paraguay Bakery Cafe | 15-07 College Point Boulevard, Flushing | ilovepy.com | +17188862331 | |
| IRIS Tea & Bakery | 39-07 1H Prince Street, Flushing | irisbakery.com | +1-718-888-1633 | |
| J |
| Jumbo Bagels | 1070 2nd Avenue, Midtown | jumbobagelny.com | +1-212-355-6185 | |
| K |
| Kosher Bagel Hole | 1423 Avenue J, Flatlands | kosherbagelhole.com | +1 718-258-4150 | |
| L |
| La Baker | 72-08 Broadway, Woodside | labaker.com | +1 347-808-7000 | |
| Little Pie Company | 424 West 43rd Street, Manhattan | littlepiecompany.com | +1 212-736-4780 | |
| M |
| M&O Bagels | 92-19 101st Avenue, East New York | | +1-718-323-3100 | |
| Maison Valero | 501 Avenue M, New Utrecht | maisonvalero.com | +1 718-924-2414 | |
| Marthas Country Bakery | 175 Bedford Ave, Williamsburg | marthascountrybakery.com | +1 718 486 0500 | |
| More Bites | 780 Saint Ann's Avenue, South Bronx | morebites.com | +1-929-251-3211 | |
| N |
| Naira Bread | East New York, no street on record | nairabread.com | +1-646-493-4065 | |
| Northside Bakerynot edited since 2018 | 77-11 76th Street, Elmhurst | northsidebakery.com | +1-718-782-2700 | |
| R |
| Radio Bakery | 135 India Street, Long Island City | radiobakery.nyc | | |
| Rockaway Beach Bakerynot edited since 2017 | 8710 Rockaway Beach Boulevard, Arverne | | | |
| Rose & Joes Italian Bakery | 22-40 31st Street, Woodside | rosejoesitalianbakery.com | +1 718-721-9422 | |
| S |
| Safir Bakery & Cafe | 1803 Kings Highway, Flatlands | safirbakery.com | +1 718-375-5888 | |
| San Jeronimo Restaurant & Bakery | 461 Port Richmond Avenue, Staten Island | sanjeronimorestaurant.com | +1 646-982-8665 | |
| Schmackary's | 362 West 45th Street, Manhattan | schmackarys.com | +1-646-801-9866 | |
| T |
| Tasty Delicious | Brooklyn, no street on record | | | |
| Tropical House Bakerynot edited since 2013 | 267 Schenectady Avenue, Brooklyn | | | |
| W |
| We Bagel | 47-11 11th Street, Long Island City | webagel.shop | +17182551992 | |
| Western Bakery Restaurant & Cateringnot edited since 2018 | 228-13 Merrick Boulevard, Far Rockaway | | | |
| Z |
| Zeppieri & Sonsnot edited since 2018 | 3004 Buhre Avenue, City Island | | | |