| A |
| AAA InsuranceAmerican Automobile Association | Far West Columbus, no street on record | | | |
| AAA InsuranceAmerican Automobile Association | Rocky Fork-Blacklick, no street on record | | | |
| AATO Insurance Agencynot edited since 2018 | 5659 Columbus Square, Northland | | +1-614-839-0669 | |
| Allstate | Hayden Run, no street on record | | | |
| AllState Insurance Agent Matt RudolphAllstate | 3719 South High Street, Far South Columbus | | | |
| American Family Insurance - Felix S. Quachey Jr. AgencyAmerican Family Insurance | 1100 Morse Road, Clintonville | | | |
| AmeriTitle Downtownnot edited since 2019 | 150 East Main Street, Downtown | amerititledowntown.com | +1-614-224-7440 | |
| Amie Kim - State Farm Insurance AgentState Farm | 1246 North High Street, Victorian Village | akinsures.com | +1-614-586-8701 | |
| B |
| Bennett Insurance Agencynot edited since 2018 | 700 South High Street, Brewery District | | +1-614-443-4226 | |
| E |
| Enterprise Insurance Agencynot edited since 2021 | 2242 South Hamilton Road, Mid-East Columbus | enterpriseinsagency.com | +1-614-759-6411 | |
| EZ Car-Surancenot edited since 2018 | 3783 South High Street, Far South Columbus | | | |
| G |
| GOREE Insurancenot edited since 2019 | Mid-East Columbus, no street on record | | | |
| Grange Insurance | 631 South High Street, Brewery District | grangeinsurance.com | | |
| Griffin Lantz Insurance Agency | Fifth by Northwest, no street on record | | | |
| J |
| John Ren Insurance Agencynot edited since 2018 | 6457 Reflections Drive, Far Northwest Columbus | johnren123.com | +1 614-923-7783 | |
| L |
| Lisa Sain - State FarmState Farm | 4444 Professional Parkway, South East Columbus | lisasain.com | +1-614-830-0450 | |
| M |
| Maloof Insurace Agency | North High Street, University District | | | |
| S |
| Solid Insurancenot edited since 2019 | Clintonville, no street on record | | | |
| State Auto Insurancenot edited since 2018 | 175 South Third Street, Downtown | stateauto.com | | |
| State Farm | Far West Columbus, no street on record | | | |
| Surety Underwritersnot edited since 2019 | Brewery District, no street on record | | | |
