| # |
| 24Hours Insurance Agencynot edited since 2021 | Valley Mills, no street on record | | | |
| A |
| AAA Braeburn VillageAmerican Automobile Association | 8120 East 21st Street, Washington Place | | | |
| AAA Greenwood / Southport OfficeAmerican Automobile Association | 1309 East Stop 11 Road, Southport | hoosier.aaa.com | +1-317-882-1521 | |
| American Family Insurance | Castleton, no street on record | | | |
| American Income Life: The West Agencynot edited since 2021 | Valley Mills, no street on record | | | |
| B |
| Brian Ciesil American Family Insurancenot edited since 2022 | 1398 North Shadeland Avenue, Warren Park | | | |
| C |
| CDC Insurance Professionalsnot edited since 2021 | North Meridian Street Historic District, no street on record | | | |
| Chuck Schoolcraft - State Farm Insurance Agentnot edited since 2022 | 1217 North Shadeland Avenue, Warren Park | | | |
| D |
| Dant Insurance Agency | 2920 Shelby Street, University Heights | | | |
| E |
| Elizabeth Marshall - State Farmnot edited since 2019 | 6124 North College Avenue, Broad Ripple | | | |
| F |
| Freeway Insurance | 5359 North Keystone Avenue, Canterbury–Chatard | | | |
| Freeway Insurancenot edited since 2022 | Warren Park, no street on record | | | |
| G |
| GEICO | Clermont, no street on record | | | |
| H |
| Hickman & Associates Insurancenot edited since 2019 | 1455 East Southport Road, Southport | hickmaninsuranceonline.com | +1-317-788-7390 | |
| Humana | Castleton, no street on record | | | |
| I |
| Indiana Farm Bureau Insurancenot edited since 2019 | 5868 East 71st Street, Devonshire | | | |
| Indiana Farm Bureau Insurancenot edited since 2018 | Fletcher Place, no street on record | | | |
| Irvington Insurancenot edited since 2022 | Warren Park, no street on record | | | |
| J |
| Jim Metzler State Farm Insurance Agencynot edited since 2017 | 2935 East 96th Street, Sherwood Forest | | | |
| Joseph H. Entezari: Allstate Insurancenot edited since 2022 | Venerable Flackville, no street on record | | | |
| L |
| Latina Insurancenot edited since 2015 | International Marketplace, no street on record | | | |
| M |
| Medina’s Multi Centernot edited since 2021 | 3906 West Washington Street, Riverside | | | |
| Monument Title Insurance Companynot edited since 2019 | 6053 North College Avenue, Broad Ripple | | | |
| N |
| Nationwide | 3905 West 96th Street, New Augusta | agency.nationwide.com | +1-317-293-7000 | |
| X |
| Xercor Insurance Services | 8425 Woodfield Crossing Boulevard, Nora | xercor.com | | |
